Status Quo

We can all agree that these are goals of a perfect EMS system.

1. A paramedic on every priority one emergency call
2. A run form completed before leaving the hospital
3. A living wage for every paramedic

Ever since I have been in EMS — 24 years now — I have heard the discussions about ambulance availability, the need to leave a fully completed documented run form before leaving the hospital, and the need to improve paramedic pay.

I recently overheard an exchange between three people, one a paramedic, one a supervisor for an ambulance service and one a hospital administrator.

Here was the rub:

The hospital wanted the paramedic to not leave for the next call before they had finished writing the run form from the first call and they wanted the paramedic on the priority one emergency call.

The ambulance supervisor wanted the run form fully completed (for billing and data reporting) and the paramedic to clear the hospital quickly to do the priority one call.

The paramedic pointed out that is was often impossible to fully complete the run form, print it out and leave it for the hospital and get to the dispatched call in a meaningful time.

The paramedic said he skipped many of the boxes on the run form so he would get the form done quickly and be able to clear. He said he sometimes cleared to take the call without leaving the run form because the patient was alert and had no issue but a cut finger. The paramedic also said many times he did fully complete the run form, but the patient was still on his stretcher when the next call came in so even though his run form was done, he couldnít clear to take the call.

The hospital administrator told the ambulance service to put more cars on the road so the paramedic could have the time to write the run form while the added paramedic did the call.

The ambulance supervisor wanted the hospital to hire more nurses so the triage lines werenít so long and so that when the nurse heard the paramedicís verbal report, they wouldnít forget it immediately because they were taking care of so many patients. And he wanted the hospital to give his company more transfers so it could make enough money to put more cars on the road.

The paramedic said while you are spending more money on hiring more nurses and putting more ambulances on the road, how about kicking a few extra dollars my way because Iím not keeping up with the cost of living despite working 60 hours a week.

The bartender interrupted the conversation then, by asking if they would all like another round, which they did. On the TV over the bar there were news stories about crumbling schools, jobs moving out of state, and other bad news.

Hereís what happened. The paramedic did the best he could to leave the run forms and get to the calls so the patients didn’t suffer. Sometimes he completed the run forms, sometimes he didnít. No nurses were hired. No cars were added. The triage lines stayed long. Calls were still dispatched before the crews had the patient off their stretcher. The paramedic did not get his raise. The three continued to drink beer together.

3 Comments

  • Brooks Walsh says:

    One thing you left out: Once the medic completes the run-form, it is faxed to the hospital, where it either is lost, buried in the warehouse of paper medical charts, or unable to be incorporated in the computerized medical record.

  • smallville says:

    Amiability is sometimes the only thing salvageable; but at least there is that.

  • Flobach says:

    When reading your three points, I thought to myself: “yes, I agree, and what’s your point?” Then I realised how lucky I have been to be a paramedic in Australia and in the uk where 1 is nearly always the case, you wouldn’t be able to clear from your previous call if you hadn’t done number 2 and number 3 hasn’t been much of an issue either (certainly not in Australia, uk pay is average but livable, with a 37.5hr week).

    What needs to change? Not only the profession needs to advance, but also the framework that it sits within (which is overwhelmingly healthcare, not public safety). But for that to happen, I believe the American public need to adopt a different mindset about healthcare and general insurance. If everyone pays in to one fund, economics of scale allow for much cheaper and better provision of healthcare. And, as we all should now working in this area, ill health and disability can hit each and anyone of us without prior notice, none of us have a magic shield of protection.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

background image Blogger Img

Peter Canning

Recent Posts
Categories
  • ems-health-safety (7)
  • ems-topics (697)
  • hazmat (1)
  • Uncategorized (407)
  • Comments
    Mark J. Tenerowicz
    Patient Handover
    I am an ED doc and EMS medical director and I expect but don't demand that my crews leave their run form before clearing. Failure to do so should be the exception, not the rule. I realize services operate in the real world of limited resources and unpredictable calls. If it being done at the…
    2014-07-16 19:57:46
    David
    Patient Handover
    The techie in me dreams there may be a technological solution, with seamless integration of pre-hospital and inpatient charts, live updating, maybe even voice recognition that would be almost like dictation, getting everything in the correct fields in the software ... then I wake up, snort and chuckle a little. Seriously though, does anyone out…
    2014-06-27 23:54:42
    Dan
    Patient Handover
    Make it so I don't have 6 cords to choose from and the driver for the printer works from HH to JMH to Children's to RGH and maybe I won't fax every single runform in. But I have been saying that for years.
    2014-05-24 18:05:52
    KellyCormier
    Patient Handover
    Peter, This is a fight that I, just like yourself and so many others have looked at in my EMS history of 25 years.I'm in a pretty unique situation as a former provider, a wife of a firefighter and someone who works with medic and firefighters across the country. I have developed a different type…
    2014-05-15 21:39:31
    Vincent
    Old Paramedics
    Hi all, I have been in well above average fitness level all my life. Three years ago, while following an EMR class, I developed the taste for First Aid work. Since then I have work in the Oil/Gas industry, and volunteer to sport events and concerts now trying to finish my PCP-IV. I have to…
    2014-05-01 00:41:50
    Give It The Best That You Have
    First Day Back
    First Day Back
    New Leaders: JFK's Nightmare
    New Leaders: JFK's Nightmare
    It's OK.
    It's OK.
    Welcome to the Club
    Welcome to the Club

    Now Available: Mortal Men

    Mortal Men is available as an electronic book for Kindle, Nook or any other e-reader. Here is a link to some of the places to buy it. The book sells for $3.99. Barnes and Noble Amazon Smashwords Scribd Also Available from iBooks

    Order My Books

    Support EMS Bloggers, Buy Their Books

    Google

    Order Books and Movies

    FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

    Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter

    LATEST EMS NEWS

    HOT FORUM DISCUSSIONS